• tgirlschierke@lemmy.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    20 hours ago

    Recognition of Palestine is good, but I’ve always thought that state recognition was a kindergarten part of international politics. From my perspective, a state exists if it controls territory de facto, and that includes Israel, even if I agree with the sentiment behind refusing to recognise it due to the illegality of its control over said territory.

    • luciferofastora@feddit.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      11 hours ago

      I think this overlooks a definitional complexity of statehood: A state as the embodiment of people inhabiting some territory has the monopoly on (legitimate) use of force within its territory, as well as the right to decide its own foreign policy. If you have a tool in your garage that I want, you get to decide if I’m allowed to come and grab it, and if I want (legitimate) access, I negotiate with you for the terms of that access (e.g. return it by tomorrow evening).

      To conflate this definition with that of an entity that controls an area opens the door for right makes might style arguments: If I break into your garage and take the tool, I now de facto have control, but that does not make me its de jure owner.

      So to recognise statehood isn’t just acknowledgement that some cultural, national, governmental or other union of people exists that could form a state or deserves to form it, but an explicit declaration that you view them as a state. It’s the difference between saying “I need that tool” and saying “I need your tool”. The tool exists, and I might have it either way, but the question who owns it is at stake and the latter phrasing implies I acknowledge your right to decide.

      Whether that definition of statehood makes sense is a separate discussion, but that’s what it means here: Do I think you have a right to govern this land and these people?