“Tech has made it easy for parents to surveil their kids all the way through college—and beyond.”

  • damnthefilibuster@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    5 hours ago

    I understand that most downvotes are coming from folks who understand that this is the privacy community. And you understand that privacy and security are at odds.

    But this is NOT about a government running secret courts to quash citizen privacy. This argument is about parents of children ranging from middle school to college time wanting to ensure that they can find out if their children are safe without looking like the nosey parent. Very often, those children have full control and ability to turn the feature off, and you’ll see from most comments of people who use this that their kids keep the feature off. You can call that conditioning, but I would call your inability to see a parent’s concern as conditioning as well.

    To my mother, it was a deep comfort to see my little dot moving on the highway and she would call me when she saw I was in the car. That way, she wouldn’t disturb me when I’m getting out of the house. That was once we’d established that I’m an adult and don’t need to be looked at from the safety perspective.

    Before that, when I was in college, I’ve had my parents question why I wasn’t in class when I should have been. They’re paying for the fucking education. They have a right to know that my labs are done and a paper is due, so I’m at home working through that.

    This is not privacy, but this is responsibility. Please, downvote it if you disagree. But do not equate privacy with a parent relinquishing their responsibility towards their child or a child relinquishing their responsibility, of studying and working and not dying in a ditch, towards their parent.

    • Seleni@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      31 minutes ago

      Yeah, I’m going to put a hard disagree on this. Because this is being a nosy parent. Just because the parents can do it behind the scenes doesn’t make it less nosy. In fact, since they can surveil their kid more completely, I’d say it’s worse.

      And really, if by college your kids aren’t mature enough to understand why they should be there and studying, that’s on the parents for not teaching them the value of education, and a tracking app is not a fix.