Which isn’t to say that there is no merit to what you said, only that it casually brushes away the fundamental nature of the universe: The universe is a machine that compresses near infinite futures towards an instantaneous actionable present and leaves in its wake a single immutable past.
We have the luxury of our actions (and especially collective actions) pushing potential futures towards or away from the statistical reality of becoming the present.
But as time marches on, you might be pushing for something that just isn’t realistically viable ANY MORE, while simultaneously driving worse outcomes to being more likely, and alternativly better-and-still-viable futures to being less likely.
The binary choice of a forced dichotomy happening in the present, sure, that’s the naïve and obvious one.
“Is my target future still viable at all?” Is the generalized decision, it is binary, and it is hard.
I admit, once the answer resolves to “no” the implication is follow up questions, like “well what is left? Of those which is best? How can I action towards that one?” But, generally, THAT set of decisions which has increasing variance based on how far you’re looking don’t even get made because people have already made the wrong choice of the earlier binary decision.
So your three assumptions don’t relate to this model at all. It makes no claim about the immutability of politicians. There is no carve out for elections. There is no general prescription for what a politician should prioritize.
The vote blue no matter who crowd? How do I feel about them? Any crowd, really? Function of time. When? A month ago? Wise. Now? Not.
“Is my target future still viable at all?” Is the generalized decision, it is binary, and it is hard.
Not really, it’s a continuum from “not at all” to “undeniably yes.” The number of meaningfully different potential answers is literally infinite. It’s only binary if you round up or down, and then you immediately have to decide your threshold for rounding. Which is to say: Even your hyper-generalized model still requires implicit assumptions to produce anything resembling a binary choice, because the world is more complicated than that.
So your three assumptions don’t relate to this model at all. It makes no claim about the immutability of politicians. There is no carve out for elections. There is no general prescription for what a politician should prioritize.
But your model also can’t on its own produce a “vote blue no matter who and don’t protest genocide” conclusion, or for that matter any concrete conclusion about what do actually do; you need more assumptions to tie it into politics in a more concrete way.
Well I strongly disagree right back.
Which isn’t to say that there is no merit to what you said, only that it casually brushes away the fundamental nature of the universe: The universe is a machine that compresses near infinite futures towards an instantaneous actionable present and leaves in its wake a single immutable past.
We have the luxury of our actions (and especially collective actions) pushing potential futures towards or away from the statistical reality of becoming the present.
But as time marches on, you might be pushing for something that just isn’t realistically viable ANY MORE, while simultaneously driving worse outcomes to being more likely, and alternativly better-and-still-viable futures to being less likely.
The binary choice of a forced dichotomy happening in the present, sure, that’s the naïve and obvious one.
“Is my target future still viable at all?” Is the generalized decision, it is binary, and it is hard.
I admit, once the answer resolves to “no” the implication is follow up questions, like “well what is left? Of those which is best? How can I action towards that one?” But, generally, THAT set of decisions which has increasing variance based on how far you’re looking don’t even get made because people have already made the wrong choice of the earlier binary decision.
So your three assumptions don’t relate to this model at all. It makes no claim about the immutability of politicians. There is no carve out for elections. There is no general prescription for what a politician should prioritize.
The vote blue no matter who crowd? How do I feel about them? Any crowd, really? Function of time. When? A month ago? Wise. Now? Not.
Not really, it’s a continuum from “not at all” to “undeniably yes.” The number of meaningfully different potential answers is literally infinite. It’s only binary if you round up or down, and then you immediately have to decide your threshold for rounding. Which is to say: Even your hyper-generalized model still requires implicit assumptions to produce anything resembling a binary choice, because the world is more complicated than that.
But your model also can’t on its own produce a “vote blue no matter who and don’t protest genocide” conclusion, or for that matter any concrete conclusion about what do actually do; you need more assumptions to tie it into politics in a more concrete way.