As reported by 404 Media, writer and musician Samantha Shokin recorded a 50-second version of Bulgarian folk song Bre Petrunko during the pandemic, initially uploading it to...
There is no case, though. DMCA notice is the last step for a YouTube takedown. They can just not do that and they’re untouchable. Protected by YouTube policy.
I think I’m missing something… What do you mean? They are being taken down without DCMA? And even if they are, if the companies claim to the content is false, there would still be a case, wouldn’t there?
YouTube has its own system for copyright claims that has nothing to do with DMCA. That only comes into play after all the appeals have played out and you’ve given all your personal information to the one false striking you. If they just stop short of doing an official DMCA notice, there’s no recourse for the actual copyright owner and no consequences for the false striker.
A case that will cost you far more than you could ever get back assuming you could get any lawyer to take it in the first place. At least with an official DMCA takedown notice there us some minimal help available against false filing.
Edit: it’s also not a guaranteed win. Everything before the DMCA takedown is all under the YouTube terms of service. Lots of judges tend to defer to that sort of contract over the law.
The entire premise of my original comment is a nonprofit taking these on so that precedence is set, reducing burden for everyone in the future. What you describe is exactly the problem this type of action solves.
Problem is they’re taking advantage of the broken youtube system. They always drop it before it gets to court.
That’s a benefit not a problem. The video being taken down means lost revenue. This should be an easy case to win.
There is no case, though. DMCA notice is the last step for a YouTube takedown. They can just not do that and they’re untouchable. Protected by YouTube policy.
I think I’m missing something… What do you mean? They are being taken down without DCMA? And even if they are, if the companies claim to the content is false, there would still be a case, wouldn’t there?
YouTube has its own system for copyright claims that has nothing to do with DMCA. That only comes into play after all the appeals have played out and you’ve given all your personal information to the one false striking you. If they just stop short of doing an official DMCA notice, there’s no recourse for the actual copyright owner and no consequences for the false striker.
But it’s still a false claim? You don’t need a DCMA to open a case?
A case that will cost you far more than you could ever get back assuming you could get any lawyer to take it in the first place. At least with an official DMCA takedown notice there us some minimal help available against false filing.
Edit: it’s also not a guaranteed win. Everything before the DMCA takedown is all under the YouTube terms of service. Lots of judges tend to defer to that sort of contract over the law.
The entire premise of my original comment is a nonprofit taking these on so that precedence is set, reducing burden for everyone in the future. What you describe is exactly the problem this type of action solves.