The best thing the US could do to start to heal international relations is to actually ratify the Rome Statute and allow the ICC jurisdiction to prosecute war crimes committed by US citizens. Bill Clinton signed the treaty in 2000, but did not submit it to Congress for consent and ratification, saying effectively they needed to see how the court worked before committing.
The United States should have the chance to observe and assess the functioning of the court, over time, before choosing to become subject to its jurisdiction. Given these concerns, I will not, and do not recommend that my successor, submit the treaty to the Senate for advice and consent until our fundamental concerns are satisfied. Nonetheless, signature is the right action to take at this point. I believe that a properly constituted and structured International Criminal Court would make a profound contribution in deterring egregious human rights abuses worldwide, and that signature increases the chances for productive discussions with other governments to advance these goals in the months and years ahead.
But then the post-9/11 Bush administration in 2002 told the UN Secretary General that they no longer intended to become State parties. Although they at least waited until it had received the required 60 ratifications to actually come into effect before pulling out instead of trying to torpedo the entire thing like the current administration certainly would.
You clearly didn’t actually read and comprehend the comment.
Ratifying the Rome Statute is what would make that a legal action in the US. Otherwise it’s just another illegal detainment and deportation to send them to the Hague. Legally, it would have to be handled internally and I think it’s fair to say no one expects that would go anywhere.
This is the mechanism to solve this issue going forwards, not just once.
There is often a gulf between should and can. If Trump pardons these people then we can use the current extradition process to make sure these criminals face justice.
Nope, I understand what it means. The point is that Trump will have pardoned people like Bovino. With the USA’s penchant for prosecuting people in other countries for for crimes committed outside the USA, we should take advantage of this precedent and encourage other countries to charge these criminals so we can extradite them to those countries to face justice.
For example, many of the people tortured in our concentration camps were Venezuelan. Venezuela could criminally charge anyone in the US involved in the false imprisonment and torture of their citizens. Once they do that, then we are free to extradite them.
So you don’t believe that your country should be able tp charge someone in another country of the crime of torturing you if that crime happened in the other country?
I believe going by the literal definition of “deport” that it doesn’t fit for someone born in the country. It suggests they arrived through a port and can have that reversed with de-portation.
Exile might be the better word? But yeah honestly Alligator Alkatraz would be more appropriate.
There is no statute of limitations for murder and no reason why the US can’t extradite Bovino to another country should they charge him with a crime.
Hopefully in 2029 a better executive branch is in charge and allows other countries to indict and try our Nazis.
edit: “change” to “charge”
The best thing the US could do to start to heal international relations is to actually ratify the Rome Statute and allow the ICC jurisdiction to prosecute war crimes committed by US citizens. Bill Clinton signed the treaty in 2000, but did not submit it to Congress for consent and ratification, saying effectively they needed to see how the court worked before committing.
But then the post-9/11 Bush administration in 2002 told the UN Secretary General that they no longer intended to become State parties. Although they at least waited until it had received the required 60 ratifications to actually come into effect before pulling out instead of trying to torpedo the entire thing like the current administration certainly would.
Ship George W Bush, and Obama, along with Trump and Biden, to The Hague.
Then the US can actually talk about anything related to international law.
You clearly didn’t actually read and comprehend the comment.
Ratifying the Rome Statute is what would make that a legal action in the US. Otherwise it’s just another illegal detainment and deportation to send them to the Hague. Legally, it would have to be handled internally and I think it’s fair to say no one expects that would go anywhere.
This is the mechanism to solve this issue going forwards, not just once.
Extradite? Did he leave the USA?
No, but he was cool with deporting us citizens to foreign counties so…
Extradite =/= deport?
If he committed some crime in another country I’d be happy for him to be extradited.
But I want him to face justice here, where he committed his crimes
Nope, extradite. See my comment below for an explanation.
Yeah, no.
He should face justice here. He can’t get pardoned by Trump for crimes levied by the states.
There is often a gulf between should and can. If Trump pardons these people then we can use the current extradition process to make sure these criminals face justice.
A physical “gulf” exists (😜) between the USA and South American countries that may what to press charges.
I believe it may be more difficult to get another country to charge the nazi brown shirt, than at least 1/50 states…
I’m with you. Extradition doesn’t mean what they seem to think it means
Nope, I understand what it means. The point is that Trump will have pardoned people like Bovino. With the USA’s penchant for prosecuting people in other countries for for crimes committed outside the USA, we should take advantage of this precedent and encourage other countries to charge these criminals so we can extradite them to those countries to face justice.
For example, many of the people tortured in our concentration camps were Venezuelan. Venezuela could criminally charge anyone in the US involved in the false imprisonment and torture of their citizens. Once they do that, then we are free to extradite them.
Bovino can be charged by the states. No extradition required. No federal pardon available.
I don’t like the idea of continuing corrupt practices. What you’ve described shouldn’t be kept.
So you don’t believe that your country should be able tp charge someone in another country of the crime of torturing you if that crime happened in the other country?
Strange.
I think it’s grey, but what you’re asking makes it sound like you want done to Bovino what’s been done illegally by the current admin.
I don’t want to continue any corrupt practices that this admin has conducted.
Break break
Can we continue this debate here instead of in two places?
I believe going by the literal definition of “deport” that it doesn’t fit for someone born in the country. It suggests they arrived through a port and can have that reversed with de-portation.
Exile might be the better word? But yeah honestly Alligator Alkatraz would be more appropriate.
*Extraordinary Rendition