Making a digital backup is only legal if you can do it without circumventing the copyright protection on the medium you’re backing up from. It’s not the backup itself that’s illegal, it’s the circumventing of copyright right protection methods that’s illegal.
I understand you’re saying that’s what’s in the law, I’m not even questioning that.
But until the law is tested in court, it’s all hypothetical. And if it hasn’t been tested in court, there’s likely a reason for that. Because precedent cuts both ways and the corporations with a stake in it know they could lose.
I’m not a legal scholar, but I feel like something like this could really go either way in court, depending on which lawyers, judges, etc. are involved.
Personally, I think they’re correct to have avoided officially taking someone to court over this. Because it would probably backfire for them.
No, making backups of media that you own is fair use. I’m pretty sure this was all tested in the courts during the VHS days, but I could be wrong.
Making a digital backup is only legal if you can do it without circumventing the copyright protection on the medium you’re backing up from. It’s not the backup itself that’s illegal, it’s the circumventing of copyright right protection methods that’s illegal.
And is there precedent for this? Or is it just speculative and never tested in court?
Well it’s written specifically that you cannot circumvent copyright protection technology to copy media in the law text where I live so…
I understand you’re saying that’s what’s in the law, I’m not even questioning that.
But until the law is tested in court, it’s all hypothetical. And if it hasn’t been tested in court, there’s likely a reason for that. Because precedent cuts both ways and the corporations with a stake in it know they could lose.
I’m not a legal scholar, but I feel like something like this could really go either way in court, depending on which lawyers, judges, etc. are involved.
Personally, I think they’re correct to have avoided officially taking someone to court over this. Because it would probably backfire for them.